The First Modern Crossword Was a Diamond Called Word-Cross

Original conceptual illustration of a diamond-shaped crossword with no black squares on an old newspaper beside a pencil

The first widely recognized modern crossword didn’t look like the neat black-and-white rectangles we fill in today. It looked like a diamond with a hole in the middle. There were no black squares, the clues used pairs of numbers, and the name wasn’t even crossword.

On December 21, 1913, the New York World published Arthur Wynne’s “Word-Cross” in its Sunday Fun supplement. A curious newspaper diversion was about to become a national habit. The Library of Congress reproduces the original “FUN’s Word-Cross Puzzle” from the December 21, 1913 World Fun section, while the Teachers College, Columbia University library documents its design and publication date.

A diamond, a blank center and no black squares

Wynne’s grid was diamond-shaped, with an empty space at its center. The word FUN was already filled in at the top. Instead of the familiar “1 Across” format, a clue told readers the numbers at both ends of its answer. One clue asked what bargain hunters enjoy; the answer was SALES. The American Crossword Puzzle Tournament’s transcription of the 1913 puzzle preserves the unusual clue numbering.

Even the original solving instructions took some getting used to. The grid contained 72 white squares and the published puzzle offered 31 clues, as documented in Smithsonian’s history of the early crossword and Columbia University’s library account. Its numbered endpoints did the organizing work that today’s black squares and familiar Across/Down labels help do. Before solving the clues, you had to get comfortable with the grid.

That is more than a cosmetic difference. A modern solver expects little numbered starting squares, black blocks separating answers and an orderly set of Across and Down clues. Wynne was still working out the format. The clever part was already there: words sharing letters, so each answer helps constrain another.

Who was Arthur Wynne?

Wynne was a British-born journalist working for the New York World. He handled puzzles for the paper’s Sunday entertainment pages, where a new word game had an obvious home. The Smithsonian’s account of the crossword’s rise describes how his unusual grid arrived as the paper was preparing its December 1913 holiday material.

Wynne called the feature “Word-Cross.” Later, newspapers began calling such puzzles “Cross-Word,” and eventually the hyphen disappeared. A printing slip is frequently given as the explanation for the reversal, but the stronger, documented point is simpler: the original 1913 feature used the other name.

It wasn’t the first word game

People had been making word squares, riddles, acrostics and intersecting-letter puzzles long before 1913. Treating Wynne as the person who invented words meeting other words would give him credit for centuries of earlier play.

His importance was popularizing the recognizable newspaper crossword format, with interlocking answers and individual clues in a grid, at a moment when mass-circulation papers could spread it widely. The distinction matters: an early predecessor can exist without being the particular newspaper format that catches on. The Smithsonian’s historical retrospective takes the same cautious view of the 1913 milestone.

In 1924, a paperback made crossword fever official

For a decade the format spread through newspapers. Then publishers Richard Simon and M. Lincoln Schuster put out a collection of crossword puzzles in 1924, reportedly including a pencil as a little nudge to buyers. The first printing was only 3,600 copies, according to the Smithsonian’s account.

That experiment took off. An original 1924 volume preserved by the Library of Congress records eleven printings in its first series and a running total of 148,200 copies for that series. Suddenly the newspaper puzzle wasn’t just a little activity between other articles. It was a product people went out of their way to buy.

Newspapers even offered prizes for solving them. The Library of Congress identifies a January 25, 1925 Omaha Morning Bee crossword contest that dangled free theater tickets for correct answers. It was the 1920s equivalent of offering a reward for doing your homework, except the homework was a grid of intersecting words.

Even the New York Times was late to the grid

It’s tempting to imagine that the New York Times invented the crossword because its puzzles are so famous now. But the Times did not publish its first crossword until February 15, 1942—nearly three decades after Wynne’s diamond appeared in a rival New York paper. Smithsonian magazine notes that particularly surprising delay.

The grid changed shape, the numbering evolved, and puzzle editors made a craft of choosing clues. If mysterious word histories are your thing, the uncertain origins of “Yankee” make for a different New York language puzzle. Yet the central bargain remained: solve one word, borrow its letters to solve another. That’s why Wynne’s slightly odd diamond still feels familiar. More than a century later, the format has changed enormously—and we’re still paying attention to the squares.


Discover more from BiggleBit

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *